Paradise Destroyed: The Destruction of Rural Living by the Wind Energy Scam Paperback – July 4, 2017

Paradise Destroyed: The Destruction of Rural Living by the Wind Energy Scam Paperback – July 4, 2017

AVON, SD  Wind energy. It’s free. It’s green. It’s healthy. It’s sustainable. And it’s lucrative for property-owners.

If only this popular narrative were true.

In Paradise Destroyed, Gregg Hubner fully exposes wind energy development for what it really is: a taxpayer scam. And not only is it a scam, but wind farms are a destructive force of 21st-century crony-capitalism that renders local communities divided and land permanently devalued.

Hubner recounts his personal experience of wind energy colonization and shares his knowledge of just how much damage wind farms can cause property and property-owners. Complete with up-to-date research on the adverse health effects of wind energy, other chapters address the bane of PURPA legislation, legal risks in signing wind-rights contracts, and a host of other related issues. Whether you are a midwestern farmer considering a wind lease, or an environmental activist trying to save the planet, Paradise Destroyed is an absolute must-read.

“. . . a remarkable service in chronicling the devastation wrought by wind farms . . . For those of us who share their love of the Great Plains, let us hope that their struggle has attained more than a stay of execution.” —JEFFREY HERBENER, Ph.D Chair of Economics, Grove City College

“This is an extremely informative book and likely to become a must-read for anyone that lives around or is considering allowing a wind farm on their property. As a physician . . . I found this book very helpful.” —THOMAS RIES, M.D.

”At present, wind energy is a losing proposition for all but those developers that benefit from government subsidization of their industry. Hubner gives an accessible overview of how and why this is truly the case.” —NORMAN HORN, Ph.D Engineering Post-Doc, MIT

Wind energy’s silent invasion – Interview with Greg Hubner from Avon, SD

People in rural South Dakota are rising in opposition to lifestyle threats brought on by industrialized agriculture and wind energy.

Surprisingly, a common foe is local government, often made up of friends and neighbors. Too often they appear to side with corporate interests instead of the people.

Sometimes it is because the law ties their hands.

Much attention has focused on agriculture, an industry transforming from family farms into industrial operations often controlled by out-of-area interests.

Meanwhile, spinning below the radar is the wind industry which is subtly changing our landscape and way of life.

It is represented as an environmentally friendly way to produce more energy and reduce air pollutants.

But it is nothing but a transfer of money from existing electric customers and taxpayers to international corporations grabbing major tax deductions.

The reward is so great that sophisticated wind farm proponents go to great lengths to ensure success, said Gregg Hubner, a South Dakota Certified General real estate appraiser from Avon. Generally, they cultivate local leaders to convince friends wind farms are a good thing.

Hubner, who has a large windfarm encroaching on his neighborhood, became so disgusted he wrote a book about industry practices. It’s called “Paradise Destroyed, The Destruction of Rural Living by the Wind Energy Scam.”

People in northeastern South Dakota should read it. New, large wind-farms are in the planning process in Deuel, Grant, Clark, Day and Codington Counties.

Codington County is vulnerable as zoning setbacks mean towers can be built 1,000 feet from occupied residences, whereas Clark County recently expanded it to .75 miles.

Deuel County residents also are fighting to expand the distance, but may be losing the battle.

Hubner said “crony capitalism” is at the heart of the wind industry with federal political leaders shoving taxpayer money into pockets of large national companies. Campaign donations often flow in reverse.

Wind towers, at $3 million each, generally can’t be supported in the private marketplace. So, the U.S. government offers tax credits, which Hubner estimated for a 43-tower project near his house to be about $6.4 million a year.

That money does not flow back to land-owners who signed property rights away for 30 years. Instead, the reward for most South Dakotans is a decline in their rural residential property value.

He cited studies showing property values dropping anywhere from 7 percent to 40 percent. Simply put, he writes, “would one build or buy a home in an industrial wind park if he could build or buy a similar home where there was no wind park?”

There are other drawbacks. Utility companies generally must buy wind power and it is more expensive than power generated from coal or natural gas. Eventually, rates are hiked and consumers pay the bill.

Other environmental issues are emerging. There is the sound of the turbines, flickers from blade shadow and ground vibrations.

Former U.S. President Barack Obama also signed legislation allowing wind operators to kill up to 4,200 eagles during a wind-farm’s 30-year life span. Multiply that by dozens of companies and the problem grows.

“Thousands and thousands of bats and birds are killed from wind turbines every year,” Hubner said.

Mostly, the addition of hundreds of wind-towers changes South Dakota’s landscape and lifestyle with little or no reward to area residents.

Hubner said wind companies are skilled at convincing a few local people to be their advocates. They pit neighbors against one another, forcing them to sign contracts preventing them from disclosing payments.

They cultivate state and federal political leaders. They lobby zoning board members and county commissioners.

They work to get zoning ordinances created in their favor. Sometimes people who sit on zoning boards have interests in the projects being considered.

When controversy hits, as we’ve seen recently, private property owners and the public have few opportunities to protest.

The rules are clear. Corporate interests win under the guise of economic development.

Hubner’s message should be heard.

The days of the little guy getting run over need to end.

Brad Johnson is a Watertown businessman and journalist who is active in state and local affairs.

SB 201 is ON THE BALLOT!!!!!!  (New: Referred Law 21)

SB 201 is ON THE BALLOT!!!!!! (New: Referred Law 21)

UPDATE on SB 201:

Jim Eschenbaum, Chair of SDPRLCA (South Dakota Property Rights & Local Control Alliance) and local control advocate,  “I was just contacted by the SOS office, we are on the ballot!!!

Jim continues, “The validation rate of your petitions was 92%, which they said was an unheard of percentage. Way to go team!!
The SOS said we submitted an estimated 31,432 signatures.

I am so incredibly humbled to be part of this effort!!
Now we need to win in November!!!
Thank You ALL for your hard work!”

Jim Eschenbaum

WIND ORDINANCE passes in Yankton County Planning & Zoning Mtg

WIND ORDINANCE passes in Yankton County Planning & Zoning Mtg

THANK YOU Yankton County residents for the GREAT turnout at the Planning and Zoning Meeting last night. The main room was packed and 20+ more were in the hallway. It is clear you are concerned about large wind complexes in our county. Thank you also to residents of other counties who are concerned about what is happening in Yankton County regarding “PROPERTY RIGHTS & LOCAL CONTROL”

The ordinance passed with few changes keeping intact two main components. It will include a 2 mile setback from non-participating residents and a decommissioning plan requiring the wind company to remove everything they put in and restoring the land to pre-construction status. The first of two readings before the Yankton County Commission will be Tuesday, August 6th at 6:00pm.

Share this link with others who have an interest in what is happening in Yankton County and across the state with “PROPERTY RIGHTS & LOCAL CONTROL”. We will see you on Tuesday, Aug. 6th.

 

Yankton County Planning & Zoning Meeting Tues. July 9, 2024

Yankton County Planning & Zoning Meeting Tues. July 9, 2024

On Monday, June 24, 28,000 signatures were filed with the SD Secretary of State in the process of getting SB201 on the ballot in November as a Referred Law.  This historic achievement gives “We the People” an opportunity to vote and show Pierre that our land is NOT for sale and decision-making stays local.
 
Jim Eschenbaum, Chair & Rep Tina Mulally, Treasurer, SD Property Rights & Local Control Alliance, filing the petitions in Pierre at the SOS office.

 

In Yankton County, SD the first meeting to protect personal property rights is Tuesday, July 9th at 7:00pm at the Government Center in Yankton. The Planning and Zoning Board is meeting to vote on an updated wind ordinance which contains new rules and guidelines for energy companies who are looking to build large wind complexes locally. This proposed ordinance reflects a fair balance between all entities and their interests, especially much needed protection for private landowners who will live among the turbines.

Your attendance and voice are needed to make sure this updated ordinance stands “as is” and is not “watered down” to favor the deep pockets of private companies. A majority vote of the Planning and Zoning Board on July 9th will pass the ordinance to the County Commission for their consideration and approval in August.

If you have any questions call Cindy at 605-660-5153 or email YanktonCountyNotForSale@gmail.com.

The proposed wind ordinance link is included below.     

Wind Ordinance Begins on pg. 48
Large Wind Energy Systems Begins on pg. 50
 
Thank you, 
 
Cindy Konopasek
SB 201 Yankton County Captain